What the sources say
Atlantic HalibutHippoglossus hippoglossus
Every figure, record and mechanism on the Atlantic Halibut profile was written from a source, and this is the working table behind it: 52 claims checked word for word against these sources. The left column is what the page says. The right column is the source's own words, copied, not paraphrased; a ... marks a cut and[brackets] an insertion. Open any source and check it yourself.
Profile updated
Source
01
NOAA Fisheries
Atlantic Halibut. NOAA Fisheries.
- The page saysThe world's largest flatfish
- The source says
Atlantic halibut is the largest species of flatfish in the world.
- The page saysSand, gravel and clay seabed of the northern Atlantic, 160 to 6,560 feet down
- The source says
Atlantic halibut are demersal fish that live on or near sand, gravel or clay bottoms at depths of between 160 and 6,560 feet.
- The page saysInvertebrates when small; almost exclusively fish from about 31 inches long
- The source says
smaller fish (up to 12 inches in length) feed almost exclusively on invertebrates. The proportion of fish in the diet increases as the fish grow in size until they feed almost exclusively on fishes when they reach approximately 31 inches.
- The page saysThe adult ends up as a right-eyed flounder. NOAA tells it from other right-eyed flounders by its size, a concave tail fin, a large gaping mouth and an arched lateral line.
- The source says
Atlantic halibut can be distinguished from other right-eyed flounders by their large size, concave caudal fin, large, gaping mouth, and arched lateral line.
- The page saysThe largest Atlantic halibut on record was taken off Cape Ann, Massachusetts, and weighed 615 pounds gutted with the head still attached
- The source says
The largest Atlantic halibut recorded was taken off Cape Ann, Massachusetts, and weighed 615 pounds (eviscerated with the head still attached).
- The page saysNOAA estimates it weighed about 700 pounds alive
- The source says
It likely weighed 700 pounds when it was alive.
- The page sayssays it can reach up to 15 feet in length
- The source says
Atlantic halibut can reach up to 15 feet in length
- The page saysFull-grown females average 100 to 150 pounds, and males tend to be smaller
- The source says
Full grown females average 100 to 150 pounds, while males tend to be smaller.
- The page saysNOAA calls it a long-lived, late-maturing species: it can live up to 50 years
- The source says
It is a long-lived, late-maturing species that can live up to 50 years.
- The page saysthe average age at maturity is about 10 years
- The source says
Average age at maturity is about 10 years.
- The page saysSmall halibut, up to about 12 inches long, feed almost exclusively on invertebrates
- The source says
smaller fish (up to 12 inches in length) feed almost exclusively on invertebrates
- The page saysThe proportion of fish in the diet increases as they grow, and by roughly 31 inches they eat almost exclusively fish
- The source says
The proportion of fish in the diet increases as the fish grow in size until they feed almost exclusively on fishes when they reach approximately 31 inches
- The page saysThey live on or near sand, gravel or clay at depths of 160 to 6,560 feet
- The source says
live on or near sand, gravel or clay bottoms at depths of between 160 and 6,560 feet
- The page saysThe range runs from Labrador and Greenland to Iceland, and from the Barents Sea south to the Bay of Biscay and Virginia
- The source says
Atlantic halibut are found from Labrador and Greenland to Iceland, and from the Barents Sea south to the Bay of Biscay and Virginia.
- The page saysIn U.S. waters, they are most common in the Gulf of Maine
- The source says
In U.S. waters, halibut is most common in the Gulf of Maine.
- The page saysNOAA's 2024 stock assessment found the stock overfished
- The source says
According to the 2024 stock assessment, the Atlantic halibut stock is overfished.
- The page saysA rebuilding plan has a target date of 2055
- The source says
A rebuilding plan to rebuild the stock to the target population level is in place with a target date of 2055.
- The page saysIn 2024, U.S. commercial landings totalled 76,000 pounds, valued at about $480,000
- The source says
In 2024, commercial landings of Atlantic halibut totaled 76,000 pounds and were valued at approximately $480,000
- The page saysfederal waters have a limit of one fish per vessel per trip
- The source says
Regulations include a minimum fish size and a limit of one fish per vessel per trip in federal waters.
- The page saysNOAA calls it the largest species of flatfish in the world
- The source says
Atlantic halibut is the largest species of flatfish in the world.
- The page saysThe Atlantic halibut is a flatfish
- The source says
Atlantic halibut is the largest species of flatfish in the world.
- The page saysUp to 15 feet long, says NOAA
- The source says
Atlantic halibut can reach up to 15 feet in length
- The page saysAn average full-grown female weighs 100 to 150 pounds
- The source says
Full grown females average 100 to 150 pounds
- The page saysThe record fish, landed off Cape Ann in Massachusetts, weighed 615 pounds with its guts removed and probably about 700 pounds alive
- The source says
The largest Atlantic halibut recorded was taken off Cape Ann, Massachusetts, and weighed 615 pounds (eviscerated with the head still attached). It likely weighed 700 pounds when it was alive.
- The page saysUp to 50 years, according to NOAA
- The source says
can live up to 50 years
- The page saysThey are slow to breed as well: on average they mature at about 10 years old
- The source says
It is a long-lived, late-maturing species that can live up to 50 years. Average age at maturity is about 10 years.
- The page saysIt depends on size
- The source says
Halibut food preferences vary by fish size
- The page saysHalibut up to 12 inches long eat almost exclusively invertebrates
- The source says
smaller fish (up to 12 inches in length) feed almost exclusively on invertebrates
- The page saysThe share of fish in the diet climbs as they grow, until at approximately 31 inches they eat almost exclusively fish
- The source says
The proportion of fish in the diet increases as the fish grow in size until they feed almost exclusively on fishes when they reach approximately 31 inches
- The page saysThe Atlantic halibut is the largest flatfish in the world
- The source says
Atlantic halibut is the largest species of flatfish in the world.
Note: vibe.reason - The page saystakes about 10 years to mature
- The source says
Average age at maturity is about 10 years.
Note: vibe.reason - The page saysweightKg: 57
- The source says
Full grown females average 100 to 150 pounds, while males tend to be smaller.
Note: task #1267: 125 lb midpoint is 57 kg; 45 to 68 kg is Medium class throughout - The page saystags: giant-size
- The source says
Atlantic halibut is the largest species of flatfish in the world.
Note: task #1267
Source
02
FishBase
Hippoglossus hippoglossus summary page. FishBase.
- The page saysNear Threatened, in an assessment from 2021
- The source says
Near Threatened (NT) ; Date assessed: 12 February 2021
- The page saysIt is uniformly dark brown or black, while young fish are marbled or spotted with paler marks
- The source says
Uniformly dark brown or black; young marbled or spotted with paler marks
- The page saysIts genus name comes from Greek for "horse tongue"
- The source says
Hippoglossus: Greek, ippos = horse + Greek, glossa = tongue
- The page saysFishBase gives 7 to 8 years for males and 10 to 11 for females
- The source says
Males reach sexual maturity at 7-8 years and females at 10-11 years.
- The page sayswith slow growth and late maturity, halibut populations can be seriously affected by overfishing
- The source says
Slow growth rate and late onset of sexual maturity, halibut populations can be seriously affected by overfishing
- The page saysFishBase says they feed mainly on cod, haddock, pogge, sand-eels, herring and capelin, but also take cephalopods and large crustaceans
- The source says
Feed mainly on other fishes (cod, haddock, pogge, sand-eels, herring, capelin), but also takes cephalopods, large crustaceans and other bottom-living animals.
- The page saysAdults are benthic, meaning they live on the bottom, though they are occasionally pelagic
- The source says
Adults are benthic but occasionally pelagic
- The page sayslives mostly on the bottom as an adult
- The source says
Adults are benthic but occasionally pelagic
Note: vibe.reason
Source
03
Bolstad & Novales Flamarique 2022
Bolstad & Novales Flamarique (2022). Chromatic organization of retinal photoreceptors during eye migration of Atlantic halibut (Hippoglossus hippoglossus). Journal of Comparative Neurology.
- The page saysa fish that moves one of its eyes across its head
- The source says
the metamorphic process whereby one eye migrates to the other side of the head
- The page saysMoves an eye to the other side of its head during metamorphosis
- The source says
the metamorphic process whereby one eye migrates to the other side of the head
- The page saysin flatfishes eye migration is the metamorphic process (a change in body form) whereby one eye migrates to the other side of the head
- The source says
In flatfishes experiencing eye migration (i.e., the metamorphic process whereby one eye migrates to the other side of the head)
- The page saysthe larva's hexagonal lattice of single cones gives way to a mostly square mosaic of four double cones around each single cone
- The source says
the hexagonal lattice of single cones present in the larva undergoes major restructuring resulting in a dominant square mosaic postmetamorphosis consisting of four double cones surrounding each single cone
- The page saysIt happens during metamorphosis, a big change in body form. In flatfishes this is called eye migration: one eye travels across to the other side of the head
- The source says
In flatfishes experiencing eye migration (i.e., the metamorphic process whereby one eye migrates to the other side of the head)
- The page saysThe retina is restructured along the way, with the larva's hexagonal pattern of single cone cells giving way to a mostly square one
- The source says
the hexagonal lattice of single cones present in the larva undergoes major restructuring resulting in a dominant square mosaic postmetamorphosis
Source
04
Sæle et al. 2004
Sæle et al. (2004). Staging of Atlantic halibut (Hippoglossus hippoglossus L.) from first feeding through metamorphosis, including cranial ossification independent of eye migration. Aquaculture.
- The page saysthe frontal bone shows torsion (a twist) correlated with eye migration
- The source says
The Frontale exhibited torsion correlated with eye migration
- The page saysmetamorphosis is protracted in halibut
- The source says
Because metamorphosis is protracted in halibut
- The page saysthough its full hardening into bone is independent of the eye's move
- The source says
calcification began earlier and full calcification was independent of ocular displacement
- The page sayswith a metamorphosis that is drawn out
- The source says
Because metamorphosis is protracted in halibut
Note: vibe.reason
Source
05
Cadrin et al. 2022
Cadrin et al. (2022). Hippoglossus hippoglossus. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2022: e.T10097A148035632.
- The page saysNear Threatened
- The source says
IUCN Red List category: Near Threatened (NT).
How the table was made: a writer drafted the profile from these sources and logged each claim with its quote, a reviewer with nothing but this table checked every sentence said no more than its quote, and a script confirmed each quote appears word for word in the source. The method is in the site'sAbout page.